Mortgage Discount Points: Finding the Break-Even Month, and How the IRS Treats Them

Published

Written by

Discount points are a fee you pay at closing in exchange for a lower interest rate. To find the break-even month, divide what the points cost by how much they cut your monthly payment. If you keep the loan longer than that many months, the points paid for themselves; if you sell or refinance sooner, they didn’t. One point is 1 percent of the loan amount.

This page works through that arithmetic and then covers how the IRS treats points, which differs for a purchase and a refinance. This is general information, not lending, tax or legal advice. Figures and links were checked on November 15, 2026.

What a point buys

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes points as an upfront fee paid to the lender for a lower rate, and gives the standard yardstick: one point on a $100,000 loan costs $1,000. Points don’t have to come in whole numbers. The bureau’s own example uses 0.375 of a point.

Lender credits are the same trade in reverse. You accept a higher rate, and the lender gives you money toward closing costs.

How much rate a point buys isn’t fixed by any rule. It varies by lender, by loan and by the day, which is why the bureau suggests asking each lender to quote the same number of points when you’re comparing offers. It also warns that some lenders use the word “points” for any upfront fee figured as a percentage of the loan, whether or not it lowers your rate.

The CFPB’s example, and its break-even

The bureau’s illustration is a $180,000, 30-year fixed-rate loan offered at 5.0 percent with no points. Paying 0.375 points, or $675, brings the rate to 4.875 percent and the payment down by about $14 a month. Taking a 0.375-point credit instead raises the rate to 5.125 percent, puts $675 toward closing costs, and adds about $14 a month.

The bureau stops there. Carrying it one step further is our arithmetic: principal and interest come to $966.28 at 5.0 percent and $952.57 at 4.875 percent, a difference of $13.71. Dividing $675 by $13.71 gives a little over 49, so the points are paid back in month 50. That’s just past four years.

A second example with assumed numbers

These figures are made up to show the method. They aren’t a quote, a typical price for a point, or a guess about where rates are going.

Line No points One point
Loan amount (30-year fixed) $300,000 $300,000
Interest rate 6.50% 6.25%
Cost of points at closing $0 $3,000
Monthly principal and interest $1,896.20 $1,847.15
Monthly savings n/a $49.05

Break-even: $3,000 divided by $49.05 is about 61.2, so the savings pass the cost in month 62, a bit past five years. Here’s the same trade at four different exits.

You keep the loan for Payment savings so far Net of the $3,000
3 years (36 payments) $1,765.80 $1,234.20 behind
5 years (60 payments) $2,943.00 $57.00 behind
7 years (84 payments) $4,120.20 $1,120.20 ahead
10 years (120 payments) $5,886.00 $2,886.00 ahead

At five years this one is basically a wash. The simple method leaves two things out. The lower-rate loan also pays down principal slightly faster, which nudges the true break-even a little earlier. And the $3,000 could have gone toward the down payment or stayed in savings, which the division doesn’t see.

The break-even month is only as good as your guess about how long you’ll have the loan. The CFPB’s version of the same point is that points tend to make sense when you expect to keep the loan a long time, and it suggests asking the loan officer to compare the options over a short, a long and a most-likely holding period.

How the IRS treats points

Points are prepaid interest, and IRS Publication 936 states the general rule first: “You generally can’t deduct the full amount of points in the year paid.” They’re deducted in equal parts over the life of the loan. None of this matters unless you itemize; our December check for homeowners covers that decision.

There’s an exception that fits most purchases. You can deduct the points in full in the year you pay them if you meet all nine tests in Publication 936. In short:

  • The loan is secured by your main home, and you used it to buy or build that home.
  • Paying points is an established practice in your area, and you didn’t pay more than is generally charged there.
  • You use the cash method of accounting, as most individuals do.
  • The points weren’t a stand-in for fees that are normally listed separately, such as appraisal, inspection, title or attorney fees.
  • The money you brought to closing, plus any points the seller paid, was at least as much as the points charged, and you didn’t borrow it from the lender or broker.
  • The points were figured as a percentage of the loan principal and are clearly shown as points on the settlement statement.
Situation Treatment in Publication 936
Points to buy or build your main home, all tests met Deduct in full in the year paid, or spread over the loan if you prefer
Points on a refinance Generally spread over the life of the new loan
Refinance where part of the money substantially improves your main home That share of the points can be deducted in the year paid if the first six tests are met; the rest is spread
Points on a loan secured by a second home Spread over the life of the loan only
Points the seller paid for you Treated as if you paid them; you reduce your basis in the home by that amount
Loan ends early (sale, payoff, or refinance with a different lender) Any points not yet deducted can be deducted in the year the mortgage ends
Refinance with the same lender The leftover balance is spread over the new loan’s term

Spreading is slow. On the assumed loan above, if the $3,000 had been paid on a refinance, it would be deducted over 360 months: $8.33 a month, or $100 for a full year. Publication 936’s own example is a $100,000, 20-year loan with $4,800 in points, which works out to $20 a month.

Not everything called a point qualifies. The publication says amounts charged for specific services aren’t interest, and lists appraisal fees, VA funding fees, mortgage insurance premiums, notary fees and document preparation costs.

What trips people up

  • Comparing a quote with points against a quote without. The rates aren’t comparable until the points are.
  • Running the break-even on the full payment. Taxes and insurance don’t change with the rate; use principal and interest only.
  • Forgetting that a refinance resets the count. If the math says month 62 and you refinance in year three, the points didn’t pencil out.
  • Expecting a full deduction on refinance points. That’s the purchase rule.
  • Trusting box 6 blindly. The lender reports points paid on the purchase of a principal residence in box 6 of Form 1098, but Publication 936 cautions that the form “may report points that you can’t deduct,” and that some deductible points may not appear on it. Form 1098, Box by Box goes through the rest of the form.

Points are priced together with the rate, so they’re only final once the rate is locked; see Mortgage Rate Locks: What the Lock Covers.

Sources

How this article was produced: Dlrow Editorial chose the question and the sources and drafted the text with the help of an AI tool. Every article is reviewed by Dlrow Editorial before it is published. If you find an error, tell us and we will fix it.