Some of the numbers on your Closing Disclosure are allowed to be higher than they were on your Loan Estimate, and some aren’t. Federal rules sort closing costs into three groups: charges that can’t go up at all, charges that can rise by up to 10 percent as a group, and charges with no set limit. Which group a fee lands in depends mostly on who gets paid and whether you were allowed to shop.
The rule is 12 CFR 1026.19(e)(3), part of Regulation Z. This is general information, not lending, tax or legal advice. Figures and links were checked on November 15, 2026.
The three groups
The regulation starts from a strict default. An estimate is in good faith, it says, “if the charge paid by or imposed on the consumer does not exceed the amount originally disclosed.” Everything else is an exception to that sentence.
| Group | What’s in it | How much it can rise | Where to look on the Loan Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| No increase | Fees paid to the lender, a mortgage broker or an affiliate of either; fees for services you weren’t allowed to shop for; transfer taxes | Not at all, unless the estimate is validly revised | “Origination Charges,” “Services You Cannot Shop For,” and the “Transfer Taxes” line under “Taxes and Other Government Fees” |
| 10 percent, as a group | Recording fees, plus required third-party services you could shop for when you picked a provider from the lender’s written list or didn’t pick one | The total of the group can exceed the estimate by up to 10 percent | “Services You Can Shop For,” and the “Recording Fees and Other Taxes” line |
| No set limit | Prepaid interest, property insurance premiums, amounts placed into escrow, property taxes, services the lender doesn’t require, and shoppable services where you chose a provider that wasn’t on the lender’s list | Any amount, as long as the estimate used the best information the lender reasonably had | “Prepaids,” “Initial Escrow Payment at Closing,” “Other,” and “Services You Can Shop For” if you went off the list |
The first row comes from the CFPB’s official commentary on the rule, which lists the charges that fall under the general rule. The second and third rows are spelled out in paragraphs (e)(3)(ii) and (e)(3)(iii).
The 10 percent test is on the total, not on each fee
This is the part people misread. The regulation looks at “the aggregate amount of charges for third-party services and recording fees.” One fee in the group can jump by far more than 10 percent, and the lender is still inside the rule if the group’s total stays within 10 percent of what was estimated. The commentary gives its own illustration: a $300 settlement agent fee inside a $1,000 group can end up above $330, so long as the group’s total doesn’t pass $1,100.
Two conditions keep a fee in this group. It can’t be paid to the lender or the lender’s affiliate, and the lender has to have let you shop for it.
“No set limit” still has a standard
The uncapped charges aren’t a free pass. Each estimate has to be “consistent with the best information reasonably available to the creditor at the time it is disclosed.” The commentary’s example is blunt: a lender that requires homeowners insurance and leaves the premium off the Loan Estimate hasn’t met that standard.
Still, these are the lines most likely to move, because nobody at the lender controls them. Your insurance quote changes. The closing date shifts by a week and prepaid interest shifts with it. The county issues a new tax bill.
When the lender can reset the estimate
A lender can swap in a revised estimate, and measure the final charge against that one, for the reasons listed in paragraph (e)(3)(iv). In plain terms:
- A changed circumstance raises a cost. The rule’s examples include an extraordinary event beyond anyone’s control, information you gave that turned out to be inaccurate or that changed, and new information the lender hadn’t relied on.
- A changed circumstance affects your eligibility, because it changed your creditworthiness or the value of the home.
- You asked for a change to the loan or the settlement.
- The rate wasn’t locked when the Loan Estimate went out. Once it’s locked, points and lender credits can change, and a revised estimate is due within three business days of the lock.
- You took more than 10 business days to say you wanted to go ahead (or longer, if the lender gave you longer).
- On new construction, closing is expected more than 60 days out and the original estimate said revisions might come.
The lender has three business days from learning of the reason to send the revised numbers. A revised Loan Estimate also can’t arrive on or after the day the Closing Disclosure is provided, and you have to receive it at least four business days before closing. If a lender simply underestimated a fee, that isn’t on the list.
Lender credits run the other way
A credit from the lender lowers what you pay, so shrinking it has the same effect as raising a fee. The CFPB’s answer to whether lender credits can decrease is “Yes, but only in certain circumstances.” Without a changed circumstance or one of the other triggering events, the bureau’s FAQ says the total can’t go down. Nothing stops it from going up.
One assumed closing, checked line by line
Every number here is made up to show the arithmetic. None of it is typical, and the provider list is whatever your own lender hands you.
| Charge | Loan Estimate | Closing Disclosure | Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Origination charge | $1,500 | $1,600 | No increase |
| Appraisal (lender-chosen) | $600 | $600 | No increase |
| Title services (provider from the lender’s list) | $1,700 | $2,000 | 10 percent group |
| Survey (provider from the lender’s list) | $500 | $500 | 10 percent group |
| Recording fees | $200 | $250 | 10 percent group |
| Homeowners insurance, first year | $1,800 | $2,150 | No set limit |
Start with the first group. The origination charge rose $100 with no changed circumstance, so $100 is over the line. Now the 10 percent group: the estimate totaled $2,400 ($1,700 + $500 + $200), which sets the ceiling at $2,640. The final total is $2,750, so the group is $110 over, even though title services alone rose almost 18 percent and the survey didn’t move. The insurance premium went up $350, and that isn’t measured against a cap at all.
Total over the limits: $210. Under paragraph (f)(2)(v), a lender that refunds the excess no later than 60 days after closing, and sends a corrected Closing Disclosure showing the refund, has complied. The Closing Disclosure rule, § 1026.38, also calls for a statement that the increase exceeds the legal limits, with the dollar amount of the excess.
What trips people up
- Checking each fee against 10 percent. The middle group is tested as a single total.
- Assuming the provider you found yourself is protected. Go off the lender’s written list and that fee moves to the no-limit group. That’s the fine print in the phrase “services you can shop for.”
- Comparing against the first Loan Estimate when a later, valid revision exists. Keep every version you’re sent, with the date you got it.
- Treating a bigger cash-to-close figure as proof of a violation. Most of that swing usually comes from the uncapped lines, and a new down payment amount or a changed seller credit isn’t a closing cost in the first place.
For what goes into the cash-to-close figure itself, see What Counts as Cash to Close Before an Offer. If a number changes after you already have the Closing Disclosure, the timing rules are in The Three-Day Closing Disclosure Rule.
Sources
- 12 CFR 1026.19, paragraphs (e)(1)(vi), (e)(3), (e)(4) and (f)(2)(v), via the Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Official Interpretation of § 1026.19, comments 19(e)(3)(i)-1, 19(e)(3)(ii)-1 through -3, 19(e)(3)(iii)-1 and -2, and 19(f)(2)(v)-1
- 12 CFR 1026.37(f) and (g), the Loan Estimate’s closing cost subheadings, via the Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 12 CFR 1026.38, content of the Closing Disclosure, statement on increases above the legal limits, via the Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, “TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure FAQs,” Lender Credits (page last modified March 15, 2024)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, “Review documents before closing” (page last modified August 21, 2025)